An unfortunately common sentiment in this world...particularly within the West. [It's awful, and definitely familiar to what Ithaqua has told him.] But to go so far as he hath...

He is deserving of punishment- that much is certain.

[Urianger wouldn't default to executing him, though. Making him live with his failure in a place where he cannot try this again should be punishment enough.

Well, they'll just have to see how the majority pans out.]